I. INTRODUCTION

Devices commonly described as smartphones are, as is well known, used not only for communication but also for transferring information and documents, accessing the internet and many other purposes. Their uses continue to expand as technology develops. Indeed, mobile phones are expected not merely to become increasingly capable and intelligent, but to converge with computers and other consumer electronics devices1.

Mobile phone users clearly constitute a large proportion of telecommunications companies’ debtors. Accordingly, methods other than conventional enforcement procedures should be sought to collect these debts as quickly and inexpensively as possible. One method that appears theoretically feasible within the legal framework is “blocking smartphones without physically attaching them.” This article considers the possible advantages and disadvantages of blocking, on account of a debt, smartphones that play an important part in all our lives and are actively used by a large section of society.

II. SMARTPHONES AND THE LAW

Although domestic law contains no precise definition of a smartphone, it may be defined as an advanced mobile communications device designed by adding the features of personal digital assistants (PDAs), products of the computer world, to the conventional features of a mobile phone2. Yet this definition does not adequately reflect how people use these devices. A mobile phone may instead be described as “an intimate socio-technological tether, worn on the body, supporting continuous, lightweight, everyday communication: a personal device”3.

Developments in communications technology have prompted changes in legal scholarship and legislation at both national and international levels. As a dynamic discipline, “law” is actively updated by scholars and lawmakers to keep pace with contemporary developments. For example, provisions concerning information technology were added to the former Turkish Criminal Code, Law No. 765 (former Code, Articles 525/a et seq.). Subsequent legislation addressed both existing situations and those likely to arise from technological developments. By way of example from the new Code, Article 158(f) of the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK) addresses fraud from the perspective of information technology. In addition, offences specific to information technology are regulated in Articles 243–246 of the TCK.

Outside criminal law, the definition of a “document” in the Code of Civil Procedure, Law No. 6100 (HMK), includes documents in electronic form (HMK, Article 199).

For the purposes of enforcement and insolvency law, “mobile phones” clearly fall within the category of movable property. Movable property comprises valuable tangible items that can be moved, have economic value and can be converted into money or valued in monetary terms. It is an economic reality that mobile phones today have value, often considerable value.

III. WHAT DOES THE METHOD SEEK TO ACHIEVE?

To explain the method discussed in this article, smartphones are used by a large majority of the population, and people clearly have something approaching an emotional attachment to them. Restricting owners’ use of these devices would place them in a position where they would have to settle their relatively small debts.

The aim is to block the communications capability of a debtor’s smartphone through public authorities, without physically attaching the device, once enforcement proceedings against that debtor have become final. In the ordinary course of events, a person wishing to use a phone whose communications capability has been blocked would be expected to pay a debt that is small in comparison with the phone’s value.

IV. POTENTIAL RISKS AND RESPONSES

The fact that mobile phones are movable property and have value is sufficient for their attachment under the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Act (İİK). Nevertheless, attaching such movable property presents certain areas of risk. These may be listed as follows:

1. Article 82 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Act — Property and Rights Exempt from Attachment “Personal Effects”

Smartphones are actively used in people’s daily and professional lives and may be regarded as part of their private lives. It might therefore be argued that they fall within the property exempt from attachment under the relevant statutory provision. This argument, however, is rebutted on two different grounds.

The first is found in Article 82 of the İİK itself (paragraph added by Article 16 of Law No. 6352 of 2 July 2012), which provides: “Where the property listed in subparagraphs (2), (4), (7) and (12) of the first paragraph is of high value, it shall be attached and sold, with an amount appropriate to the debtor’s circumstances being left to the debtor from the proceeds to meet the relevant need.” Thus, where such property is of high value, attachment is permitted to the extent necessary to satisfy the claim. As noted above, smartphones are valuable items. Many less expensive alternatives can perform the same function.

Secondly, the measure discussed in this article is not a physical attachment and does not seek to take the debtor’s smartphone away and subsequently put it through a sale process. The proposed measure is to prevent its use and/or disposal by having public authorities disable its communications capability (block it). Calls could not be made using a smartphone whose communications capability had been disabled, but all its other features would remain available. This is intended to secure payment of a debt considerably smaller than the smartphone’s value.

2. Article 20 of the Constitution — Privacy

The relevant article states: “Everyone has the right to demand respect for his or her private and family life. The privacy of private and family life is inviolable.” Given the functions of smartphones, they are highly likely to contain information relating to an individual’s private life, such as personal photographs and writings.

In support of this point, the United States Supreme Court delivered a precedent in Riley v. California. Under that decision, examining data on a mobile phone requires a court order. Law enforcement officers may not examine such data without one4. The Court thereby recognised that smartphones are no longer merely devices for communication, but have also become devices containing personal data. In addition to that recognition, however, the Court made an exception in the following terms: “…the fact that technology allows an individual to carry such information in his or her hand does not make that information any less worthy of the protections for which the Founding Fathers fought5…” Reading this decision in its legal context, the inference is that personal data may be examined where the public interest is taken into account.

In Türkiye, too, where there is a court order, there is nothing unlawful about smartphones being examined and reported upon by court-appointed experts.

However, this issue presents no risk for the purpose of the proposal discussed here. The intention is not to take into custody the device containing the debtor’s personal data. Because the device would remain in the debtor’s possession, all personal data would remain secure. The data contained in a blocked mobile phone would remain with the debtor, away from any danger. To reiterate, the debtor would be unable to use only the smartphone’s telephone function; its remaining features would stay active. Accordingly, there would be no interference with privacy.

3. Article 22 of the Constitution — Freedom of Communication

The article provides: “Everyone has freedom of communication. The confidentiality of communication is fundamental.” This provision does not present even the slightest risk in relation to blocking mobile phones. As is well known, service providers enable communication through the “SIM card” supplied to users. Under the proposed method, there would be no blocking of, or interference with, the debtor’s SIM card. After the debtor’s mobile phone had been blocked, the debtor could insert the SIM card into any other mobile phone and continue to use it. The debtor whose smartphone had been blocked would not be able to use that phone by inserting a SIM card from any service provider. Freedom of communication would therefore remain unrestricted.

4. Article 82(3) of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Act — Necessary Items

The relevant provision states: “Except for valuables such as money, negotiable instruments, gold, silver, precious stones, antiques or ornaments, items necessary for the debtor and family members living under the same roof, and, where there is more than one item used for the same purpose, one of those items… may not be attached”6.

This raises the question of which items should be treated as exempt from attachment. Under the final paragraph of Article 82 of the İİK, this decision is left to the enforcement director. Oral discussions with Ankara enforcement offices indicated that the smartphone’s market value was used as a criterion in this assessment. To explain again, since the blocked phone would not be taken from the debtor or made the subject of a sale, this issue falls entirely outside the area of risk. By blocking the debtor’s smartphone, we seek to create a compelling incentive to pay a debt that is small in amount.

V. IMPLEMENTING THE METHOD

The procedure would be carried out entirely through official authorities by means of formal written requests. Once the statutory periods had expired and enforcement proceedings against the debtor had become final, the enforcement office would first be asked to send a formal request to the Information and Communication Technologies Authority (BTK). In brief, that request would state that enforcement proceedings against the debtor had become final and ask whether there was an IMEI number associated with the debtor’s Turkish identity number. If a matching IMEI number existed, the request would ask for the relevant smartphone to be BLOCKED.

Blocking a smartphone means disabling communications solely for the device identified by the relevant IMEI number.

The BTK’s own statements establish that it can block a smartphone by reference to its IMEI number7. There is no legal obstacle to applying this within the framework of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Act.

VI. CONCLUSION

In practice, conventional enforcement methods such as attaching vehicles, physical attachment, attachment of immovable property, attachment of wages and formal requests to banks may be effective for debts above a certain amount. For debts below that threshold, however, these methods increase costs and require expenditure that can approach, or even exceed, the principal claim. Leaving the settlement of small debts entirely to the debtor’s initiative makes their collection almost impossible.

If the proposed method is followed, it is clear that the greatest benefit could be obtained at the lowest cost in securing payment of small debts. Debtors would thereby be given a compelling incentive to pay. There is no legal obstacle to implementing this method, which is also highly efficient in cost–benefit terms.

We consider that this method, which parallels the blocking of a bank account and electronic attachments imposed by tax offices, would enable small debts to be collected swiftly.

Footnotes

  1. Pei Zheng/Ni Lionel, Smart Phone and Next Generation Mobile Computing, 2006, pp. 6–7.

    ↩
  2. https://tr.0wikipedia.org/index.php?q=aHR0cHM6Ly90ci53aWtpcGVkaWEub3JnL3dpa2kvQWvEsWxsxLFfdGVsZWZvbg

    ↩
  3. Mizuko Ito, Personal, Portable, Pedestrian Mobile Phones in Japanese Life; ed. Mizuko Ito/Daisuke Okabe/Misa Matsuda, London, 2005, p. 1.

    ↩
  4. Riley v. California, p. 11.

    ↩
  5. Riley v. California, p. 28.

    ↩
  6. The amendment to the İİK dated 2 July 2012 replaced the concept of “household items” with “necessary items.” We therefore consider that smartphones may also be assessed within this concept.

    ↩
  7. The BTK’s statement reads as follows: Individuals whose mobile phones have left their possession without their consent must call the Information and Reporting Centre established within the Information and Communication Technologies Authority on 0312 294 94 94, which operates 24 hours a day, seven days a week, to have their phones blocked from communications.

    If you provide the Centre with your IMEI number, identity details and the time when you last used your phone, the phone is blacklisted once the information is verified. This prevents the blocked device from being used with a SIM card belonging to someone else.

    Before a reported phone is blocked, a text message is sent to it warning that the device has been stolen and must be handed over to the nearest law enforcement authority.

    ↩