Crimes at sea began when humankind first became active on the seas and continue to this day. Maritime offences are grouped under three headings: privateering, piracy and theft at sea.1 “Privateering,” used by states to create private fleets resembling mercenary or legionary forces; “piracy,” committed on the high seas for private interests; and “theft at sea,” committed along coasts in areas that would now be described as territorial waters, are frequently confused and used interchangeably.

Neither in the past nor today has there been a definition of piracy commanding complete consensus. International legal scholarship has offered a variety of definitions. According to Calvo, it is “any act of theft or plunder against a non-enemy ship, in time of peace or war, and any armed act of violence or plunder against the person or property of a foreigner on the high seas.”2 In the 1920s, Pella defined it as follows: “Piracy consists of acts committed for gain and on one’s own account, in places not subject to the sovereignty of any particular state, involving violence against persons and plunder of property, thereby endangering the safety of navigation in those places.”3 Almost all such scholarly definitions have shortcomings or aspects that have attracted criticism.

The definition currently taken as the basis for piracy is that adopted by the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. It reads: “Piracy consists of any of the following acts:4

a) Any illegal act of violence or detention, or any act of depredation, committed for private ends by the crew or passengers of a private ship or aircraft, directed against another ship or aircraft on the high seas, or against persons or property on board it; or against a ship, aircraft, persons or property in a place outside the jurisdiction of any state;

b) Any act of voluntary participation in the operation of a ship or aircraft with knowledge that the ship or aircraft is a pirate ship or aircraft;

c) Any act intended to incite or intentionally facilitate the acts described under A and B.”

This definition and the concepts within it have been criticised for their lack of clarity. One of the most ambiguous concepts is “unlawfulness”5: the English text of the Convention uses “illegal,” while the French text uses “illicite.” The former is more closely associated with contravention of the law, the latter with illegitimacy. Each country’s law differs, and the absence of uniformity in international law gives the concept a breadth sufficient to create difficulties in applying the law.

Another contemporary criticism of the definition is that it requires “violence or detention or depredation” for piracy to occur. Today, however, particularly in Southeast Asia, pirates can board ships under way or at anchor, steal cargo, cash or equipment unnoticed, and leave.6 In other incidents, the same pirates may interfere with their target ship or aircraft through violent acts, or employ violence after secretly boarding a vessel. Requiring actual violence before an act can be classified as piracy creates a loophole for “pirates” and constitutes a deficiency in the definition.

“They cannot stop us. Even if foreign navies catch some of my crew, I do not worry at all. As has happened several times before, my men will probably receive no punishment other than a free ride back to the beach. We know international law.”7

Jama Ali, pirate leader

There are certain common elements in both international legal scholarship and the definitions used by international associations and organisations. Even without consensus on a single definition, these common elements may provide a route towards a generally applicable and objective definition.

1- THE ACT MUST TAKE PLACE ON THE HIGH SEAS OR IN A PLACE OUTSIDE ANY STATE’S JURISDICTION

Both international law and states’ domestic laws have always characterised piracy as an offence peculiar to the high seas. In addition to the high seas, however, the act may take place on land belonging to no one, described in law as terrae nullius. Today, such areas are virtually non-existent, and the likelihood of offences being committed there is very remote.8

According to Rudgier Wolfrum, the rationale for this limitation is that the coastal state is responsible for combating piracy in maritime areas subject to its sovereignty.9 Leaving aside the label of piracy, all the acts that constitute it represent separate offences under states’ domestic laws. Since territorial waters also fall within a state’s sovereign domain, those committing such acts would face criminal sanctions without any need for a new term—piracy.

2- THE ACT MUST BE COMMITTED FOR PRIVATE ENDS

Under this common element, whether an act constitutes piracy depends on its being committed for private ends. Acts not committed for private ends are said not to constitute piracy. But what is meant by a private end, and what should its scope be? Looking at the issue solely through traditional law would narrow its meaning, because traditional law required an intention to steal or plunder. Events have shown that piracy is committed not only for these motives, but also for personal motives such as revenge and hatred, which are at least as common. The definition has therefore moved beyond the bounds of traditional law.

“The pirate’s usual purpose is plunder, and the usual target is the ship’s cargo. Yet whether the pirate does only that, kills the crew, seizes or sinks the ship, kills just one passenger, or abducts a passenger for ransom, the perpetrator remains a pirate.”10

3- THE ACT MUST BE COMMITTED BY A PRIVATE SHIP OR AIRCRAFT

This element identifies the vessels capable of committing piracy and broadens the scope. It nevertheless raises another question: what happens if a state-owned ship commits the same act? When a warship commits acts constituting piracy, it directly engages the responsibility of the state whose flag it flies—the flag state.11 The flag state must both compensate the damage and punish the captain. Only where a public vessel uses its power entirely for private ends, damaging or threatening another state’s or a private person’s vessel, property or persons on board, does it lose its character as a public vessel, so that its conduct may be considered piracy.

4- AN ACT OF PIRACY MUST INVOLVE MORE THAN ONE SHIP

The requirement for at least two ships means that there must be a ship or aircraft that has become a pirate vessel, and that it must interfere with another ship in a manner constituting piracy. A ship cannot commit piracy on its own, against itself or by attacking land.

Acts such as mutiny or collective indiscipline by the crew are not considered piracy. They also lack the intention of enrichment and private gain necessary for piracy.12 Since seizure of a ship by its own crew or passengers is not piracy, there is no threat to international security in such circumstances. The authority to suppress the mutiny should therefore lie with the flag state.

THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN PRIVATEERING AND PIRACY

The Turkish term “deniz haydutluğu,” distinguished from “korsanlık” or privateering, is now established in legal language. Both scholarship and normative legal texts use the proper term for piracy, “deniz haydutluğu.”

A privateer was an entrepreneur who, under a licence from a sovereign, attacked and plundered enemy ships and subsequently paid a commission to that sovereign. The practices, authorisations and sanctions governing privateering varied from country to country and even from one sovereign to another. Some privateers obtained licences from a governor or a semi-autonomous sovereign power rather than a monarch, and the form of the licence or permission could be written or oral. Privateering may be described as a contract for services under which a private enterprise exercised authority obtained from the sovereign in return for paying the state a share of the proceeds as commission.

The expansion of states’ sovereign domains, and the inability of their subjects to protect or enlarge those domains, gave rise to the practice known since the Middle Ages as mercenary or legionary service. Privateering is nothing more than a form of mercenary service performed on behalf of a state. Piracy, by contrast, involves no sovereign power. The perpetrators’ nationality is immaterial, because they act independently of sovereign authority and solely in their own interests.

The 1856 Declaration of Paris, signed after the Crimean War between the Ottoman Empire and Russia, prohibited privateering internationally for the first time. The Declaration brought wartime attacks on merchant ships within the framework of the modern law of armed conflict. Although the removal of privateering from the literature through the Declaration might appear to have resolved the confusion between privateering and piracy, contemporary films and novels cause the distinction to be overlooked.

Privateers and pirates used similar methods of combat. The seafaring population from which practitioners of these two “professions” were recruited and into which they were transformed largely comprised the same marginal individuals.

After the 1856 Declaration of Paris, no state issued a licence or authorisation for privateering. Nevertheless, an arrangement adopted during the Franco-German War in 1870 gave rise to an accusation of privateering. The North German Confederation had very few military personnel, and it was decided to establish a fighting fleet of merchant ships. Acting as president of the Confederation, the King of Prussia called on all German merchant ships to join the navy. After each ship had been valued, its owner would receive hire equal to ten per cent of that value; the personnel would wear naval uniforms, and the ships would sail under the German naval ensign. If a ship was destroyed, the owner would be paid its full value. The French government argued that this arrangement was a disguised breach of the Declaration of Paris’s prohibition of privateering and requested the United Kingdom’s intervention. The British government referred the matter to legal advisers. When they concluded that the arrangement differed from privateering, France’s request was rejected.13

JURISDICTION OVER PIRACY

The problem of trying and punishing captured pirates has reached an impasse over the form of jurisdiction to be exercised at sea. In international law, the high seas are described as de facto areas: spaces between states that belong to none. Even today, international law concerning the high seas is not highly developed.

In international law, jurisdiction is used in a broader sense than in domestic law. It is defined as the authority or legal power that states possess to carry out their governmental functions.14 In international criminal law, however, its scope is narrower. There, jurisdiction is defined as “the powers a state possesses under international law to investigate and punish the commission of an offence.”

Piracy is a situation that goes beyond the traditional definition of jurisdiction and transcends states’ sovereign boundaries. It raises the concept of universal jurisdiction, which stands above individual states’ jurisdiction and, in a sense, extends it.

The origins of universal jurisdiction over pirates lie in their treatment, since Roman law, as enemies of humankind (hostes humani generis). The principle that ownership of property plundered by pirates does not change, which also remains valid today, dates back to the Middle Ages.

The principles of jurisdiction may be examined in relation to piracy as follows:

1- THE TERRITORIALITY PRINCIPLE

The territoriality principle may also be expressed as territorial jurisdiction. It denotes a state’s jurisdiction over its territory. Every state is entitled to exercise jurisdiction over acts committed within its sovereign domain. Offences that do not end where they begin have, however, led to the development of this principle. States may exercise jurisdiction over acts that begin within their territory but are completed outside it; this is referred to as subjective territoriality. They may also exercise jurisdiction over acts initiated outside their sovereign domain but completed within it; this is referred to as objective territoriality.

Lakes, rivers, internal waters and territorial waters within a state’s boundaries make up its maritime territory. The territoriality principle also encompasses this maritime territory. Consequently, persons hiding or carrying out piratical acts within a state’s territorial waters will be pursued, apprehended and tried by that state.

The scope of jurisdiction available to states under the territoriality principle does not end at the outer limit of territorial waters. In the contiguous zone beyond those waters, states may also exercise jurisdiction over health, customs, fiscal matters, immigration and historical remains. These subjects form an exhaustive list and do not include piracy. States therefore have no jurisdiction over pirates in the contiguous zone arising from the territoriality principle. The same applies to another maritime area, the exclusive economic zone, where the matters in which a state may intervene are likewise exhaustively listed and its jurisdiction is limited.

Offences committed on vessels registered with a state also fall within that state’s jurisdiction by virtue of the territoriality principle. Under this principle, vessels are treated as though they were islands within the state’s territorial boundaries.

2- THE NATIONALITY PRINCIPLE

This is one of the oldest known legal bonds between a state and its citizens. The nationality principle has developed beyond dependence solely on the offender’s nationality—the active nationality principle—to recognise jurisdiction in the state of nationality of the victim—the passive nationality principle. Since ships attacked by pirates fall within the jurisdiction of a flag state, the passive nationality principle is understood to permit the states to which the injured persons and the ship belong to exercise jurisdiction over the incident and apply their own laws.15

Legal persons, ships and aircraft must be under a state’s flag or, in other words, affiliated with it. Article 91 of the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) regulates the nationality of ships. It provides that ships have the nationality of the state whose flag they are entitled to fly. The same article stresses the need for a genuine link between the ship and the flag state. The purpose is to prevent ships from appearing to possess the nationality of countries that readily permit the use of their flags.

As a rule, under Article 92 of the 1982 UNCLOS, ships navigating on the high seas are subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of their flag state. The flag state’s jurisdiction is subject to exceptions expressly stated in the Convention, and one such exception is “piracy.”

3- THE PROTECTIVE PRINCIPLE

To protect their vital interests, states have jurisdiction over offences committed against them outside their territory that threaten their security. Traditionally, the protective principle applies in matters involving unlawful immigration, protection of the currency and certain economic interests. It provides a particularly important basis for combating terrorism. There are contemporary efforts to bring piracy under the heading of terrorism, but the issue remains contested.

4- THE UNIVERSALITY PRINCIPLE

The universality principle has been recognised as a basis of jurisdiction to bring within the law persons who hide from prosecution in places subject to no state’s sovereignty, or where states do not wish to exercise, or do not exercise, jurisdiction. In the absence of the traditional bases of territoriality and nationality, universal jurisdiction allows states to exercise jurisdiction, subject to certain limitations. In the words of International Court of Justice judge Georges Abi-Saab: “Universal jurisdiction is jurisdiction of last resort, a measure required by urgency and necessity.”16

Universal jurisdiction recognised by treaties is generally regarded as mandatory, whereas universal jurisdiction arising from international custom is considered discretionary for states. Piracy is a typical example of discretionary universal jurisdiction. Although piracy has become established in international law and appears in conventions, states’ universal jurisdiction in this field has remained discretionary.

The high seas are a global commons outside states’ territorial jurisdiction. Ships navigating on the high seas, however, are registered with particular states and are subject to the jurisdiction of the state whose flag they fly. As noted above, because ships attacked by pirates fall within a flag state’s jurisdiction, it must be accepted under the nationality principle that the states to which the injured persons and the ship belong have jurisdiction over the piracy incident. The place where piracy occurs therefore does not render the standard rules of jurisdiction inapplicable.

Authority to impose sanctions on pirates is exercised in both private-law and criminal proceedings. Piracy has two aspects. The first is a violation of the common rights of nations, for which pirates are punished under international law by the seizure of their ships. The second concerns criminal sanctions, under which offenders are punished according to the domestic law of the country in which they are tried.

PIRACY IN STATES’ DOMESTIC LAWS

Every state may adopt provisions concerning piracy in relation to its own citizens and persons or ships within its sovereign domain.

Under international law, every state may exercise jurisdiction over pirates committing piracy on the high seas. International law does not prescribe the penalties that states must impose on captured pirates; this authority is left to states. Although customary international law recognises states’ right to combat piracy, the security of international waters depends entirely on their individual efforts and their cooperation with one another. Since there is no universal definition of piracy, states are free to use the definition they choose.

The Republic of Türkiye has no statute enacted specifically on piracy. Persons involved in piratical acts are tried and punished under the relevant provisions of the Turkish Criminal Code adopted in 2004. Article 13(1) of the Code lists offences subject to the principle of universal jurisdiction. Accordingly, Turkish law may apply where the specified offences are committed abroad by a citizen or a foreign national. The listed offences include hijacking or detaining sea, rail or air transport vehicles (TCK, Article 223(2)–(3)) and criminal damage to such vehicles (TCK, Article 152).

That the wording of the Criminal Code also covers piracy can be understood from the heading of Article 223: “Offences against Means of Transport or Fixed Platforms.” The article contains no provision specific to piracy; the conduct it regulates is “preventing a land transport vehicle from moving, stopping it while in motion, or taking it to a place other than its intended destination, through force, threats or another unlawful act.” Where the vehicle is a land vehicle, the penalty is imprisonment for one to three years; for a sea or rail vehicle, two to five years; and for an aircraft, five to ten years.

As can be seen, the Turkish Criminal Code contains neither a definition of piracy as an offence nor a specific penalty for it. The adopted definition—preventing a vessel from moving, stopping it or taking it somewhere other than its intended destination—is far removed from the definition accepted in international law.

For states to combat the new forms of piracy effectively, it is important that they bring their domestic laws into line with current conditions. Some international organisations have contributed by preparing model national legislation. Combating the new piracy to be examined under the heading of piracy in the twenty-first century requires new regulation at both international and national levels.

Article 13 of the Turkish Criminal Code, Law No. 5237, embodies the universality principle. The offences listed in it may be tried in Türkiye regardless of the nationality of the offender or victim, and regardless of whether the Turkish state has been harmed. The offences that may be tried are listed in the provision as follows:

a) Offences set out in Book Two, Part One.

b) Offences set out in Chapters Three, Four, Five, Six, Seven and Eight of Book Two, Part Four.

c) Torture (Articles 94 and 95).

d) Intentional pollution of the environment (Article 181).

e) Manufacture and trafficking of narcotic or psychotropic substances (Article 188), and facilitating the use of narcotic or psychotropic substances (Article 190).

f) Counterfeiting currency (Article 197), manufacturing and trading in instruments used to produce currency and valuable stamps (Article 200), and counterfeiting seals (Article 202).

g) Prostitution (Article 227).

h) Bribery (Article 252). h) (Repealed pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 5918 of 26 June 2009.)

i) Hijacking or detaining sea, rail or air transport vehicles (Article 223, paragraphs 2 and 3), or criminal damage to such vehicles (Article 152).

Regardless of where the offences listed above are committed, the Republic of Türkiye, which might appear to lack jurisdiction under other principles, has incorporated the universality principle into the Turkish Criminal Code through Article 13 and declared itself competent. Accordingly, offences committed within the scope of piracy may be regarded as triable in the Republic of Türkiye under subparagraph (i), within the universality principle defined by the Code.

CONCLUSION

Piracy emerged through individual ships using various forms of violence against other vessels at sea in pursuit of private gain. It consists of offences committed on the high seas for private interests, entirely independently of authority and without ties to states.

Neither international legal scholarship nor the codification work of international associations has produced a definition on which consensus has been reached. Consequently, the prosecution of piracy as a matter of international law differs between countries. In Türkiye, no statutory criminal-law rule comprehensively regulates piracy. Nevertheless, the universality principle set out in Article 13 of the Turkish Criminal Code addresses the prosecution of this type of offence to a limited extent. Article 223 of the same Code also provides a sanction for hijacking or detaining vessels and taking them somewhere other than their intended destination.

Piracy is an offence seen predominantly in the eastern Indian Ocean. International-law efforts are currently being made to prevent piracy and punish such offences. These efforts have not, however, yet taken concrete form.

Footnotes

  1. Kerem BATIR, Deniz Haydutluğu ve Uluslararası Hukuk, Uşak Yayınları, 2011, p. 1.

    ↩
  2. A.Emre ÖKTEM – Bleda R. KURTDARCAN, Deniz Haydutluğu ve Korsanlık, Denizler Kitabevi, 2011, p. 53.

    ↩
  3. ÖKTEM – KURTDARCAN, p. 53.

    ↩
  4. Birleşmiş Milletler Deniz Hukuku Sözleşmesi, http://www.unicankara.org.tr/doc_pdf/denizhukuku.pdf, last accessed 22 May 2013.

    ↩
  5. ÖKTEM – KURTDARCAN, p. 56.

    ↩
  6. ÖKTEM – KURTDARCAN, p. 56.

    ↩
  7. ÖKTEM – KURTDARCAN, p. 137, http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/16/world/africa/16pirate.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0, last accessed 23 May 2013.

    ↩
  8. ÖKTEM – KURTDARCAN, p. 58.

    ↩
  9. BATIR, p. 116.

    ↩
  10. ÖKTEM – KURTDARCAN, p. 62.

    ↩
  11. ÖKTEM – KURTDARCAN, p. 65.

    ↩
  12. ÖKTEM – KURTDARCAN, p. 68.

    ↩
  13. BATIR, p. 88.

    ↩
  14. Permanent Court of International Justice, S.S. Lotus Case, Publications of the Permanent Court of Internationa Justice, Series A – No. 10, p. 19; Uğur BAYILLIOĞLU, Somali Sahilleri ve Açıklarında İşlenen Deniz Haydutluğu Fiillerine Karşı Yürütülen Mücadelenin Hukuki Dayanakları ve Türkiye’nin Durumu, Gazi Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi, Vol. XV, 2011, No. 1, p. 129.

    ↩
  15. BATIR, p. 51.

    ↩
  16. BATIR, p. 53.

    ↩